Filmed: June 12-14, 2014 | Aired: October 22, 2014
- Ep5 Reward challenge: None, tribal swap instead
- Ep5 Immunity challenge: "Shakedown Street" - The athletic NuHunahpus completely obliterate NuCoyopa.
- Ep5 voted out: Kelley, in an unnecessarily confusing 3-2-2 vote, over Dale and Baylor.
Episode 5 scoring notes
- Records-in-progress note: Baylor continues to receive votes at an astounding pace, with 9 in four trips to Tribal Council. She has also been voted against at every Tribal she's attended, a streak of four straight. This is tied for the second all-time longest opening Tribal votes received/survived the vote streak of all time, with Rudy in Borneo and Cochran in South Pacific. Rory in Vanuatu has the longest opening streak (five Tribal Councils), but was voted out in his sixth.
Vote count:
- Kelley received 3 votes, from Baylor, Missy, and Jaclyn (voted out, 3-2-2).
- Baylor received 2 votes, from Dale and Kelley.
- Dale received 2 votes, from Jon and Keith (neither of whom have voted anyone out).