
I’m a little late with this mid-season review, and don’t have a legitimate excuse. Maybe I’ve been enjoying this season’s players so much I lost focus. I was on the road for a week but that didn’t stop me in earlier seasons. I have some catching up to do.
But first, I’ll go straight to this week’s Damnbueno Open Era random reference.
Rafe Judkins
Rafe played what I consider an almost perfect game of Survivor in S11: Guatemala. This was the first season to feature popular returning players mixed with rookies. Rafe and the other 15 rookies cheered when they saw Stephenie LaGrossa and Bobby Jon Drinkard jogging out to play the game with them. Just one month earlier, the finale for S10: Palau had aired. The entire Guatemala cast were eager to align with the veterans, hoping to make a deep run with players who knew how the game worked. Nobody did this better than Rafe. He quickly became Stephenie’s most trusted partner. Rafe’s social and strategic games were excellent too. Stephenie consulted with Rafe on every decision as they remained in the same camp together for the entire game.

Stephenie was overcompensating for mistakes she made in Palau. She was getting too aggressive and rubbing people the wrong way. This was perfect for Rafe who had a much stronger social game. Rafe would subtly smooth over things with players when they got angry with Stephenie’s bullying (much like Trish Hegarty did with Tony in S28: Cagayan). He was making friends with all the future jurors while Stephenie was giving them reasons not to vote for her at the end. At one point, Lydia, Danni and Cyndy called themselves “Rafe’s Angels.” Rafe gave himself multiple options to reach the finals. In addition to his deals with Stephenie, Lydia, and Cyndy, he made a final 2 deal with Danni, and they didn’t share a camp until after the merge. Rafe’s physical game was strong too. He won four Individual Immunity Challenges and one Reward challenge, yet nobody targeted him for being a challenge beast. While Stephenie was scorching the earth, arguing with Cyndy and Lydia and executing blindsides (which were planned by Rafe) on jurors Jamie and Judd, Rafe was making himself the best-liked and most-respected player in the game. Then he listened to his heart.
Rafe, Stephenie and Danni made it to the final 3 Immunity Challenge which required endurance. Rafe lasted an hour and a half and was eliminated when he touched a pole by mistake. Then he sat and watched Stephenie and Danni compete for another hour. Danni was so comfortable she looked bored, but Stephenie was adjusting, contorting and groaning regularly. When Stephenie dropped out, Rafe committed my #3 biggest Bonehead move. He felt bad for Stephenie who’d competed so hard. So, instead of pressuring or guilting Danni into honoring their final 2 deal, Rafe said “Danni, I want to release you from any promise you made to me about who you took to the final two. Take whoever you want tonight, I’m serious about that, I mean it, ok?” Rafe handed Danni a guilt-free reason to put him on the Jury. That’s exactly what she did on her way to a 6-1 win over Stephenie, whose only vote came from Rafe –- the only juror who wasn’t angry at her.

Many fans say there was no way Danni would ever take Rafe to the finals. But fans said the same thing about Colby taking Tina (S2), Woo taking Tony (S28) and Erik giving his Immunity to Natalie (S16). Rafe removed Danni’s opportunity to make a mistake like that. At a minimum, he should have tried to nudge her in that direction.
The only one playing similar to Rafe this season is Cristian. He hasn’t been on anyone’s radar all season long. He’s good at puzzles and did well in the pairs Immunity Challenge. Thien An and Sharonda are close, but Thien An doesn’t have the cross-Tribal relationships Rafe had, and Carter outed Sharonda as a “leader” early on.
Here’s my brief review of each player’s game so far, in alphabetical order.

Many fans have compared Carter to J.T. There are similarities. Both are farmers. There are physical similarities too. And like J.T., Carter found himself out of the information loop just like J.T. was in his first season (S18: Tocantins). Carter started out rough, picking a horrible partner in Rob, who quit. He also picked a bad partner in Ana who got too aggressive and made herself a target. But dumb luck fell his way when Rob handed him an Idol off camera (which normally is not allowed). Then he bumbled a chance to get another Advantage, letting an Extra Vote slip through his fingers while visiting the other camp. Then he unintentionally mutinied to Toka (which also helped him) when the boat left without him. But since then, he has made some smart decisions. He connected with Lewis and helped change the power structure on Toka. Then at the merge, he found a way to reconnect with his original Savu tribemates even though he was certain they were going to vote him out if he hadn’t mutinied. That was very smart. But then he told Cristian about his Idol, which may come back to haunt him as that information gets spread around. Carter also caught a huge break when Cristian’s Shot In The Dark hit, which allowed him to hold on to his Idol. Carter has proven he’s got some strategic chops and can build trusting relationships. But he continues to fall on the wrong side of the votes. He has voted four times and “missed” on three of them. His ability to get a better read on the room will determine his fate. He can win the game but must figure out how to get out of his own way first.

As I mentioned in the intro, Cristian hasn’t made any enemies. So far, everyone seems to like him just fine. He’s got several players including him in on their plans early in the process, which means he’s trustworthy. He has made connections with players from both tribes and hasn’t stood out as any kind of target yet. Cristian has shown some strong strategic instincts too. When his swapped tribe piled their votes on Lewis, who got saved by Maggie’s Extra Votes, Cristian was the only one who saw the wisdom of approaching Lewis and Kilby with the idea of working with them after the vote. That led to Lewis connecting him with Devin, Jelly, Maggie and Mike. After seeing how Kristin had so much heat thrown her way after going on a Journey, Cristian chose to be totally transparent when he was forced to go on one. He got an Extra Vote out of it, even if Mike witnessed it, and likely told everyone about it. Just the same, everyone likes and respects Cristian. If he can navigate past the coin flip and fire challenge, he’d be a strong candidate for the win ... if he doesn’t shoot himself in the foot down the stretch.

Devin came out of the gate way too hard and fast, smiling and forcing his charm on others at every turn. I thought for sure he was only playing to make himself famous as opposed to trying to win. His dedication to “weaponized honesty” seemed doomed to backfire. I thought the Survivor Gods were punishing the camera-hungry narcissist by blowing out all of his partners (Aaliyah, Patt, Ori) in rapid succession. It even looked like he was getting bad reads or creating tension within his own alliance when Jelly chose to tell Patt about her Idol and didn’t tell Devin. But since the merge, Devin appears to have made a huge adjustment. He has largely kept his mouth shut. Devin was the only one who wasn’t trying to push the vote during the Brady vs Eric whisper fest. The morning after Brady left, Devin stayed by the shelter with Thien An instead of getting in the middle of the larger group gathered by the boat. He hasn’t figured out how to keep his head off the chopping block though. He got eight votes last week and had to be saved by Jelly’s Idol. People are used to writing down his name, so I doubt he’ll make it to the final 3. But if he does, he’s got a puncher’s chance of talking his way into a win. It looks more to me like either Devin or Jelly will be gone soon and the other will make a deep run. Duos are just too threatening. Both of them have shown they’re aware of this and might have to separate. The question is who will turn on the other first? I think that will be Jelly.

It became clear to me early on that Eric has two primary goals. 1) He’s here for the adventure. He wants to experience everything Survivor has to offer, and 2) He’s here to make himself memorable. From shouting out his wife and mother’s names to spending hours fishing instead of joining an alliance to begging Probst to eat a grub before a challenge even begins to endlessly babbling Survivor trivia and quotes from favorite shows, Eric has shown he’s just not focused on winning the game. He has no idea how annoying he can be to those around him. At the same time, he seems to be fooling himself into thinking he’s controlling the votes. When he showed his vote for Brady, he said “Don’t ever rat out when I’m trying to help you and gain your trust. You crossed the vampire, time to get bit.” He seems oblivious to the fact that others manipulated the voting after his attempts failed because he’s too busy mugging for the camera. If you’re asking nine other people to have an “open forum” to find out who vote for you, you just don’t understand how people win Survivor. I could see Eric jumping at the chance to flip the coin. I could just as easily see him being the finals goat or getting disposed around final 6 when his vote is no longer needed by a stronger player (like Sharonda or Cristian). But he’s not winning this game.

Jelly seems to have been in conflict the entire game. She was initially attracted to Ori and joined the hastily formed Helicopter alliance (with all black players) primarily because he was in it. But when she found an Idol, she didn’t tell Devin, she told Patt, who wasn’t in the Helicopter alliance. Jelly realized early on that being so close to Devin would hurt her individual game, but has stuck closer to Devin than anyone else, choosing their partnership over Alexis, then Ori, and then playing her Idol when it could protect them both. She seemed happy to follow Devin’s lead even after his decisions put her on the wrong side of two straight votes. But since the merge, it seems their roles have reversed. Jelly absolutely took the lead in getting Brady voted out. But she’s still having trouble reading the room. Jelly had no idea she and Devin were everyone’s target until Sharonda spelled it out for her. Devin’s lone vote removed Kilby and Kristin, but we don’t know if Devin & Jelly split their votes on purpose. Did they not realize that voting differently could have produced a tie in which they couldn’t control the outcome? Maybe they didn’t speak at all and just got lucky. Either way, Jelly has been so attached to Devin, it might be too late to break away from him without following him out the door at the next vote. Jelly might not be able to get to the finals without Sharonda and Devin, and she might not be able to beat either of them. Nobody needs a plan B more than Jelly.

Lewis has a natural, disarming charm that is in part due to his Irish accent. Out of everyone left in the game, who doesn’t like Lewis? We’ve seen Kilby, Carter, and Thien An call Lewis their #1. We’ve seen those three, Maggie, and Cristian approach Lewis with strategic plans. We’ve also seen Lewis pull Sharonda into some trust. We’ve seen Lewis get caught in lies (about his “Blood Idol”) but still maintain trust from those who knew he was lying to them. Lewis seems to be bullet proof. My fear with Lewis is that this will catch up to him, and everyone will realize how tough it will be to beat him in the finals. Lewis has the same kind of “there for the adventure” vibe as Eric, but he’s much more strategic, and likes to create chaos. It won’t surprise me at all if Lewis flips the coin. If he gets past that, I could see him lasting long enough to get thrown into the fire challenge. But he’s very dangerous if he reaches the finals.

Maggie is a very smart player who sees all the angles. Her biggest problem is she has absolutely zero poker face and comes off as indecisive and flighty. She’s smart enough to search the boat for the Advantage in Carter’s note but was one of the last ones there when several headed to the boat. But when nobody found it the first time, Maggie knew to keep trying. When interrupted by Brady, she handed over the axe, enabling Brady to grab it. But then she worked his emotions well enough to get it back from him. Who knows what it was that alarmed Maggie about Linnea and Kristin on day 1, but she appears to have been right about both of them. At the same time, she seems to have fallen asleep on Sharonda, who was the first one Maggie hugged when the merge was announced. Maggie was initially convinced by Kilby to go after Eric, then became obsessed with removing Kristin out of fear she held an Idol or Advantage. Then she appeared to make an emotional decision to remove Brady for exposing that plan after being nudged in that direction by Jelly. It says a lot to me that nobody even considered putting a vote on the duo of Mike & Maggie, even though a huge majority wanted Mike gone at the previous vote. Does this mean everyone trusts and values Maggie or do they completely dismiss her as a goat? I’m not sure, but if Maggie makes it to the end, she’s gonna have a difficult time owning her game because most of the possible jurors seem to see more as a follower. It appears that right now, the only ones Maggie could out talk for the win are Eric and Mike. Who else can she beat?

Mike isn’t winning the game. He has just created too many reasons not to want him to succeed. Several players have said it’s hard to trust him because he doesn’t give any information. That makes Mike difficult to trust as an alliance partner and very suspicious as an adversary. Mike has been caught sharing strategic plans several times. And as his experience with Kristin proved, Mike can often be unaware of how he comes off to others. He doesn’t read the room well. You can’t change how others perceive you if you never know how they feel about you in the first place. That makes it very difficult to outwit anyone. But since Mike’s chances of winning are so low, that might buy him a free ride into the final 5. Why boot someone who nobody wants to win when you can take out a real threat instead? Mike is most likely fire challenge fodder thrown in by the Immunity winner to take out the biggest threat.

I only see two negatives in Sharonda’s game which is otherwise very solid. First, when Thien An asked her who she wanted to vote for, Sharonda responded by saying “I’m not voting for Devin & Jelly.” That turned Thien An from someone who wanted to work with her into an adversary. Thien An immediately knew she couldn’t manipulate how Sharonda votes. That’s the kind of player most want to remove. Second, Sharonda appears to be more dedicated to Devin & Jelly than they are to her. Sharonda established a close partnership with Kristin even before she became part of the Helicopter alliance. But even though Kristin trusted Sharonda with all the information about the Tethered Idol, protecting Kristin was a lower priority to Sharonda than protecting Devin & Jelly. Sharonda didn’t want to vote Kristin out, but she opened up that possibility by warning Jelly without suggesting a different target. It figures that Jelly wouldn’t want to remove Mike because she can influence how he votes. But why wouldn’t Sharonda suggest booting Thien An and Eric instead? Is Sharonda carrying Eric’s vote in her own pocket? We did see Sharonda targeting Carter & Cristian, but we don’t know how hard she pushed for that result.

It’s tough to evaluate Thien An’s game because we just haven’t seen much of it. But what we’ve seen so far has been pretty impressive. At her first trip to Tribal Council, it was Thien An who read the room right and knew the “Vibe 5” alliance of Devin, Jelly, Brady, Patt and Mike had to be taken out. She chose Patt as the glue to that alliance who had the strongest social game (she was right, too - that alliance slowly crumbled as Brady bulldozed his way through it). Edgic readers might write Thien An off because she hasn’t had much screen time. I don’t buy that because we’ve seen too many other “invisible” winners (Vecepia, Danni, Chris Underwood, Erika) for me to write off Thien An. She has already shown me she’s got the strategic chops to manipulate the vote and avoid the blow back. There are a couple of danger signs though. Thien An allowed herself to get paired with Eric right after she watched him get four votes. She has missed on each of the merge votes so far. She stood right in front of Jelly and Maggie as they whispered and decided to vote for Brady. It appears Thien An still voted for Eric, even though she knew Brady was a goner. That could cost her Eric’s possible jury vote. Thien An is a smart player and reads the room well enough to outtalk anyone in the game if she reaches the finals.
Could Cristian make a bonehead move similar to Rafe’s by volunteering to flip the coin? Can Maggie increase her level of respect enough to win? Can Devin & Jelly make it to the end intact? What’s Sharonda’s path to the finals now that she doesn’t have an Idol to save her? Let’s find out.
And away we go ...
I still want to know where Devin & Jelly’s phony Idol came from.
I’m not sure why Devin & Jelly are celebrating so much. They’re still the #1 targets in the game, and now they don’t have an Idol to protect them. Jelly says, “Now these people have to grovel to me.” Is it possible for them to be more wrong? They need to find a way to stop getting their names written down. But at least Devin says (in confessional) the two of them decided to split their votes.

Eric returns the now useless Extra Vote to Cristian. That still doesn’t make any sense to me for Eric. He could have forced a tie with someone. Or if he kept it and didn’t tell Cristian, he could bluff with it himself later on. Yeah, Eric just doesn’t know what he’s doing in this game.
I still think Carter was better off not telling Cristian about his Idol too. Simply knowing about the Idol gives Cristian the power to turn votes against Carter, should he want Carter gone for any reason.
You see??? You see???

I’ll start the timer. Sharonda tells someone (Devin & Jelly?) about Carter’s Idol in 10 ... 9 ...
It sure looks like Sharonda is playing the best game now. But that coin flip and fire challenge are still ahead of her.
Maggie has the right idea in wanting to go Idol hunting. But then Maggie gets the wrong idea and asks a bunch of people to do the same thing.
Devin is still patting himself on the back for hiding a phony Idol. Has he thought about who he wants to find it? What if someone he wants to keep around (Sharonda?) finds it? He’d be better off sticking close to someone he wants to vote out and hiding it near where he/she is looking like David did with Jay in S33: Millennials vs. Gen X. He and Jelly should also prioritize finding their possibly re-hidden Idol.
Yup, just like I thought. Jelly is still the #1 target. She still needs an Idol. And people might remember to split the votes next time.

Nice, a Reward-only challenge. Not so nice, they’re splitting into teams. I’m not even gonna hope we get to see the schoolyard pick if they have one. I know we won’t. As cool as a helicopter trip is, the smarter player stays at camp and finds that Idol.
Of course we don’t get to see the picks. Mike easily picked the stronger team. They should get to the slingshots first. But if Mike still wants Devin & Jelly gone, he should have kept them on the same team. He’d have a better time keeping track of them.
Mike’s team reaches the slingshots with a slight lead. Maggie takes the first shot for Sharonda’s team. It doesn’t look like anyone is sandbagging, but why not have Carter shooting first?
Lewis hits all three targets for Mike’s team and wins it…but he also loses by enhancing his challenge beast image after effectively sandbagging in the last challenge. You don’t want Probst screaming about how well you’re performing at final 10.

Mike in confessional: “Lewis really came through big time. He’s been one of the best people in every challenge.” Yeah, he’s in full Challenge Beast mode. He has won two straight challenges now, and finished second in another.
I wonder if someone is gonna stumble onto an Advantage on the Reward trip like Sol did on his Reward in S47?
Is there an echo in here?

And just like that Lewis leaps to the top of the hit list. He’s Cristian’s top target now.
Devin: “I will 100% flip the coin if nobody else desperately needs it.” I say, “You fool, you fool!” And it was Mike of all people who nudged him in that direction.

I wonder if they could take any food back to the others?
It’s a little ironic that Jelly – a member of the Helicopter alliance – now hates the sight of a helicopter.

And it’s Lewis who babbles about how good the food was to the starving tribemates. This dude is burying himself worse than Cyndy in S11: Guatemala when she did the same thing.
Eric: “I’m gonna be sitting pretty because no one’s looking at me.” That’s because you’re too annoying to win the game.
There’s been a lot of talk about booting Lewis. Too much talk. Now I’m thinking he wins Immunity.
Wait, now Jelly wants Maggie out? Jelly, your “boot Lewis” plan was working. Sure, it’s nice to set someone up as a backup, but don’t kill your first plan until you know who has Immunity. This could easily backfire on her.

Devin smartens up and decides to try and lead Maggie to his phony Idol.
But he quite literally points it out to her and “finds” it in front of her. I suppose that could help keep votes off of him if she blabs to others about it. But dude, they can still split votes between you and Jelly. But come on Devin! Try adding just a tiny bit of subtlety to your game.

I’m sorry, I have to say it. Devin was a dumbass here.
I remember this challenge from S45. Katurah was terrified of falling into the water and had a panic attack. Austin ended up winning it.

Lewis finishes 2nd and Carter wins Immunity. This makes it interesting. Who did more damage to their game? Jelly with her aggressive targeting, or Lewis with his challenge performances? Will Devin bluff votes off of Jelly and onto himself?
Lewis in confessional: “Did I just up my oomph my physical threat level?” Yes dude, but you did that one challenge ago. You had the right idea when you and Sharonda sandbagged in the last Immunity Challenge. You had no business winning this Reward Challenge. You took the spotlight role and killed it.
Jelly boomerangs back to targeting Lewis. And there’s Sharonda in the middle of the discussion again. Maybe she IS carrying Eric as her pocket vote.

But Maggie, Thien An, and Carter want Jelly gone. It’s a pretty safe bet Lewis will want that too.
Thien An in confessional: “My target is Jelly. She never looks at me or tries to strategize with me. That’s a door that’s closed.” That’s also a reason Thien An might not vote for Jelly if she makes it to the finals. Bad job on Jelly’s social game here. But nothing is stopping Thien An from approaching Jelly either.
Cristian swears his loyalty to Carter, but he has already spilled the info about Carter’s Idol.

Devin point-blank tells Lewis, “I’m writing your name down.” Lord knows why he’s so dedicated to “weapoinized honesty,” but he just told Lewis to find an Idol or create a good reason to go after someone else (like Devin). I have to say it again. Devin is a dumbass.
Lewis should tell everyone, “Devin just said he’s voting for me. It’s only a matter of time until he’ll do it to you.” Lewis should know how much this group hates people who leak information. He thinks it’s gonna be a tie vote. That’s a bad plan. You can’t play your Shot In The Dark. You need to change some minds.
It doesn’t look like Lewis came up with a plan B. but stranger things have happened. Devin can swing it with his Extra Vote, but has he figured that out?

Yeah, I think the most annoying players (Mike and Eric) have a free ride into the final 6.
Wow, Devin, Cristian, Eric and Lewis all say they want to flip the coin??? Lewis is in trouble, so his decision makes sense. But everyone else is a dumbass for even considering it.
Devin confirms this cast saw Rick Devens flip the coin last season. I wonder if they got to see all of S50?
Kristin and Kilby’s faces reflect my thoughts: “Don’t be a dumbass!”

Devin’s big mouth made Lewis extra aggressive about wanting to flip the coin. That’s another reason he made a dumbass decision.
Lewis lets Devin flip the coin. I’ll be honest, I hope Devin fails.
But wait, there’s more talking to do.

Lewis chooses to control his fate. Now I hope he hits it and Devin gets booted.
Probst puts down a coin flipping pad. Last season, the coin rolled over several planks of wood. I guess that won’t happen this time.
Lewis chooses the fire side of the coin, and it comes up water. Lewis is gone.

Lewis reflects my feelings when he says, “I chose my fate.” So much for the “Salt” alliance.
Recap
I feel bad for Thien An. Two votes in a row she lost an ally because they made a bad call. Kilby chose a bad partner to pair with, and Lewis made himself too big of a target with challenge performances. She’s got some major adjustments to make.
I don’t feel as bad for Lewis because he should have known not to do so well in those challenges. He was smart enough to sandbag last week. What was he thinking? Lewis was too much of a risk taker. He set himself back about 10 steps in volunteering to go to Exile on day 1. I guess he never really recovered from that setback. He didn’t even think to bluff with his own phony Idol. He was playing catch up until he sprinted ahead of the pack.

Cristian was smart to hint to others he’d be willing to vote Lewis out. Now they may be open to working with him. I’m most interested in how he plays the rest of the game. He has already exposed Carter’s Idol. Will he sell out Carter now?
I suppose it’s possible Devin deserves some props even though I called him a dumbass. He might have intentionally manipulated Lewis into flipping the coin. My gut says Devin was still willing to flip it himself. The Jury is out on this one, but either way, Devin took all the heat off of Jelly.
I’m thinking Carter is in trouble. He totally trusts Cristian, who now has the power to blindside Carter because he can talk him into holding onto his Idol. And with Carter’s allies dropping like flies, Cristian may want cut him loose, especially if he thinks Carter will only play his Idol for himself.
What do you think? Who’s positioned best to get to the end? Did Devin trick Lewis into flipping the coin? Where does Maggie stand? Is she a threat or a goat? Let me know in the comments.
Damnbueno got his nickname in 8th grade Spanish class when his friend shouted out "You're pretty damn good at Spanish." The teacher insisted he say it in Spanish, so the friend said "Esto es damn bueno en Espanol." The nickname stuck. These days, when he's not forgetting his 8th grade Spanish, Damnbueno is indulging his obsession with all things Survivor. Reach him in the comments section here at True Dork Times.