Natalie Tenerelli - Survivor: Redemption Island
Natalie Tenerelli on social media: twitter | Instagram
Seasons: 1 | Days: 39 | Wins: 0 | Final Three: 1

Survivor: Redemption Island (2011) - 3rd place, no jury votes.

  • Received zero jury votes, to finish 3rd (8-1-0) in Episode 14, "Seems Like A No-Brainer" (Day 39).

Survivor: Cambodia - Second Chance (2015) - part of the voting pool, but did not place within the top 10 female candidates for slots.

Natalie Tenerelli - Career statistics
Challenge stats Tribal council stats Jury stats
Season ChW ChA ChW% VFB VAP TCA TC% wTCR JVF TotJ JV% SurvSc SurvAv
S22: Redemption Island 1.64 11.02 0.15 12 1 13 0.92 5.17 0 9 0.00 1.07 6.81
Career 1.64 11.02 0.15 12 1 13 0.92 5.17 0 9 0.00 1.07 6.81
Natalie Tenerelli - Challenge record
  • S22 logo Redemption Island challenges

    Crash Course - Ep7 RC/IC

    Tribal/team challenge record (4-for-7)

    • Redemption Island Ep.1 RC/IC: "Push It Uphill" - Competes, and Ometepe loses.
    • Redemption Island Ep.2 RC/IC: "Smash, Grab, Smash" - Works the lock for Ometepe, but again, Ometepe loses.
    • Redemption Island Ep.3 RC/IC: "Spin Cycle" - On Ometepe's wheel, Ometepe 'wins' (Zapatera throws the challenge).
    • Redemption Island Ep.4 RC/IC: "Toolin' Around" - Stands around, performs no active roles, Ometepe loses.
    • Redemption Island Ep.5 RC/IC: "Smoko" - Blindfolded Natalie follows Rob's directions, Ometepe wins.
    • Redemption Island Ep.6 RC/IC: "Beach Balls"- Make a lot of successfully caught shots, Ometepe wins.
    • Redemption Island Ep.7 RC/IC: "Crash Course"- Goes through the obstacle course, and Ometepe wins.


    Rollerballs - Ep8 IC

    Individual challenge record (1-for-10): (Mean % finish: 38.2%)

    • Redemption Island Ep. 8 IC: "Rollerballs" - Outlasts all, into the three-ball phase; Natalie wins! (1st/12).
    • Redemption Island Ep. 9 (F11) IC: "Meso Soup" - Eliminated in the first round (tie-7th/11).
    • Redemption Island Ep. 9 (F10) IC: "Gang Hang" - Last to drop, letting Andrea win (2nd/10).
    • Redemption Island Ep. 10 IC: "Mayan Pizza"- Eliminated in first round (tie-7th/9).
    • Redemption Island Ep. 11 (F8) IC: "Log Jam" - Loses to Phillip in the first round (tie-5th/8).
    • Redemption Island Ep. 11 (F7) IC: "Memory" - With Phillip, first people eliminated, on the 4th card (tie-6th/7).
    • Redemption Island Ep. 12 IC: "Step On It"- Beats Phillip out in the race for last place (6th/6).
    • Redemption Island Ep. 13 IC: "Bone to Pick" - On a not-very-hard challenge, last place again (5th/5).
    • Redemption Island Ep. 14 (F5) IC: "A Numbers Game" - Once again, sole possessor of last place (5th/5).
    • Redemption Island Ep. 14 (F4) IC: "Meso Maze" - Appears to lose track of things, dead last (4th/4).


    Redemption Island duel record (0-for-0):

    • Redemption Island: None.
Career challenge totals
  • Team/tribal challenges
    Wins: 4
    Played: 7
    Win%: 0.57
    Sat out: --
  • Individual challenges
    Wins: 1
    Played: 10
    Win%: 0.10
    Mean% Finish: 38.2%
  • Duels
    Wins: 0
    Played: 0
    Win%: --
    Mean% Finish: --
Natalie Tenerelli - Tribal Council record
  • S22 logo Redemption Island Tribal

    Final Three

    Idols held/played (0/0):

    • Redemption Island: None. Rob would not allow it.


    VFB - Votes for the person booted (12/13):

    • Redemption Island, Ep. 2: Matt Elrod (voted out, 4-2-[0]).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 4: Kristina Kell (voted out, 4-3).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 8: Matt Elrod (voted out, again, 6-5-1).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 9 (F11 vote): Mike Chiesl (voted out, 6-5).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 9 (F10 vote): David Murphy (voted out, 6-4).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 10: Julie Wolfe (voted out, 6-3).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 11 (F8 vote): Ralph Kiser (voted out, 6-2).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 11 (F7 vote): Steve Wright (voted out, 6-1).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 12: Andrea Boehlke (voted out, 5-1).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 13: Grant Mattos (voted out, 4-1).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 14 (F5 vote): Andrea Boehlke (voted out again, 4-1).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 14 (F4 vote): Ashley Underwood (voted out, 3-1).


    VAP - Votes against (1):

    • Redemption Island, Ep. 13: One vote, from Grant.


    Jury votes received (0/9):

    • Redemption Island, Ep. 14: Received zero jury votes, to finish third (8-1-0).
Career Tribal Council totals
  • Hidden idols
    Found: 0
    Played: 0
    Votes voided: --
  • Voting record
    VFB: 12
    Tribals: 1
    VAP: 13
  • Jury votes
    Made: 0
    Received: 0
    Total jurors: 9
Natalie Tenerelli - Pictures
  • S22 logo Redemption Island image gallery (click to expand/collapse)
  • S31 logo Cambodia image gallery (click to expand/collapse)
Natalie Tenerelli - Interviews
Natalie Tenerelli - Bio
  • S22 logo Redemption Island bio

    From her EW photo caption:

    "The teenage beauty had not watched much Survivor before she was cast, but ended up on the show after being on a professional volleyball dance team — don't worry, we have no idea what that is either — with Jennifer Parker of The Amazing Race (season 12). And she's already looking for another young hottie to partner up with. 'I definitely want to align with a girl — a younger girl. Because I feel like if I'm not in an alliance with another girl that they will be jealous of me if say, I'm with two or three other guys.'''


    Excerpts from her official CBS bio page:

    "Personal Claim to Fame: Being the youngest female to play the game.

    Survivor Contestant You Are Most Like: Natalie White from Samoa.

    Why you think you'll 'survive' Survivor: I have never quit anything that I have ever done and hopefully my ability to form good relationships with people will help me to 'survive' 39 days in this game!

    Reason why you think you will be the sole Survivor: I have the charm to win people over and a good intuition about people and their intentions. People may suspect me to be young and naive, but they will be fooled!"