Andrea Boehlke - Survivor: Redemption Island, Survivor: Caramoan, Survivor: Game Changers
Andrea Boehlke on social media: twitter | Instagram
Seasons: 3 | Days: 103 | Wins: 0 | Jury: 3

Survivor: Redemption Island (2011) - 5th place, 16th out - 8th juror.

  • Longevity totals: In-game - 34 days; Redemption Island - 3 days.
  • Voted out in Episode 12, "You Mangled My Nets" (Day 32).
  • Returned to the game and was voted out again in Episode 14, "Seems Like a No-Brainer" (Day 37).

Survivor: Caramoan - Fans vs. Favorites (2013) - 7th place, 14th out - 5th juror.

  • Voted out in Episode 12, "The Beginning of the End" (Day 33).

Survivor: Game Changers (2017) - 8th place, 13th out - 6th juror.

  • Voted out in Episode 13, "Parting Is Such Sweet Sorrow" (Day 33).

Andrea Boehlke - Career statistics
Challenge stats Tribal council stats Jury stats
Season ChW ChA ChW% VFB VAP TCA TC% wTCR JVF TotJ JV% SurvSc SurvAv
S22: Redemption Island 2.14 10.02 0.21 7 9 11 0.63 1.37 - - - 0.84 3.64
S26: Caramoan 2.07 7.90 0.26 6 13 8 0.73 1.24 - - - 0.99 3.30
S34: Game Changers 3.84 8.31 0.46 5 14 8 0.60 0.97 - - - 1.06 4.81
Career 4.21 17.92 0.23 18 36 27 0.66 1.21 - - - 0.97 3.89
Andrea Boehlke - Challenge record
  • S22 logo Redemption Island challenges (click to expand/collapse)

    Crash Course - Ep7 RC/IC

    Tribal/team challenge record (4-for-7)

    • Redemption Island Ep.1 RC/IC: "Push It Uphill" - Competes, and Ometepe loses.
    • Redemption Island Ep.2 RC/IC: "Smash, Grab, Smash" - Smashes tiles for Ometepe, and again, Ometepe loses.
    • Redemption Island Ep.3 RC/IC: "Spin Cycle" - One of Ometepe's wheel riders/spitters, and Ometepe 'wins' (Zapatera throws the challenge).
    • Redemption Island Ep.4 RC/IC: "Toolin' Around" - "Competes" but does nothing, Ometepe loses.
    • Redemption Island Ep.5 RC/IC: "Smoko" - Blindfolded Andrea follows Rob's directions, Ometepe wins.
    • Redemption Island Ep.6 RC/IC: "Beach Balls" - Catches no balls facing off against Julie, but Ometepe wins.
    • Redemption Island Ep.7 RC/IC: "Crash Course" - Competes, Ometepe wins.


    Gang Hang - Ep9 IC

    Individual challenge record (1-for-8): (Mean % finish: 56%)

    • Redemption Island Ep.8 IC: "Rollerballs" - First person out in the third (final) round (9th/12).
    • Redemption Island Ep.9 (F11) IC: "Meso Soup" - Eliminated in the first (of three) rounds (bottom 5 of 11).
    • Redemption Island Ep.9 (F10) IC: "Gang Hang" - After negotiating with Natalie and Andrea, wins immunity (1st/10).
    • Redemption Island Ep.10 IC: "Mayan Pizza"- Makes it to final round, but Rob & Steve finish ahead of her (3rd/9).
    • Redemption Island Ep.11 (F8) IC: "Log Jam" - Loses to Ashley in the first round (bottom 4/8).
    • Redemption Island Ep.11 (F7) IC: "Memory" - Along with Grant, eliminated on the 5th card (tie-4th/7).
    • Redemption Island Ep.12 IC: "Step On It"- Close, but behind Rob & Grant (3rd/6).
    • Redemption Island Ep.13 (F5) IC: "A Numbers Game" - Finishes behind Ashley & Rob (3rd/5).


    Redemption Island duel record (1.25*-for-2):

    • Redemption Island Ep.13 Duel: "A Maze N' Jig" - Third to finish, but stays alive (3rd*/4).
    • Redemption Island Ep.14 Duel: "A Leg Up" - Wins, and returns to the game (1st/4).
    *Note: Non-elimination duels count as partial wins, in this case, third place as a quarter-win.
  • S26 logo Caramoan challenges (click to expand/collapse)

    Hot Pursuit - Ep7 RC

    Tribal/team challenge record (8-for-12; 1 sit-out):

    • Caramoan Ep.1 RC: "Water Slaughter" - With Brandon, wins the point against Hope & Eddie, and Bikal wins.
    • Caramoan Ep.1 IC: "A Long Way to the Top" - With Cochran, tosses crates down from the first floor, but after Malcolm tosses, Bikal loses.
    • Caramoan Ep.2 RC/IC: "Plunge, Pull & Pop" - With Brenda & Erik, one of three divers, and Bikal wins.
    • Caramoan Ep. 3 RC/IC: "Cell Block Sea" - Competes, Bikal wins.
    • Caramoan Ep. 4 RC: "Head and Shoulders" - With Brenda, one of the people carried, Bikal wins.
    • Caramoan Ep. 4 IC: "Smash & Grab" - Smashes tiles for Bikal, Bikal wins, again.
    • Caramoan Ep. 5 RC: "Nut Bucket" - Sits out (with Dawn & Erik), as Bikal wins.
    • Caramoan Ep. 6 IC: "Crate Outdoors" - Now switched to the new Gota, which promptly wins big.
    • Caramoan Ep. 7 RC: "Hot Pursuit" - Competes, new Gota wins again.
    • Caramoan Ep. 7 IC: "Phoenix Rises" - Opens locks, pulls the rope, Gota wins again.
    • Caramoan Ep. 9 RC: "Jump Shot" - Part of the losing team (with Dawn, Malcolm, Phillip, Brenda).
    • Caramoan Ep. 10 RC: "Muddy Waters" - Part of losing team (with Sherri, Malcolm, Brenda, Eddie).


    Bermuda Triangles - Ep12 F8 RC/IC

    Individual challenge record (1-for-6): (Mean % finish: 70%)

    • Caramoan Ep. 8 IC: "Caramoan Catering" - Makes it to second round, but not the 3rd or 4th (tie-4th/12).
    • Caramoan Ep. 9 IC: "Last Gasp" - Good effort to stay in, but eventually loses in a tight battle with Brenda (2nd/11).
    • Caramoan Ep. 10 IC: "Keel Hauling" - Makes it to the final (second) round, but ends behind Reynold and Malcolm (tie-3rd/10).
    • Caramoan Ep. 11 IC: "Drop A Log" - Fifth person to drop out (5th/9).
    • Caramoan Ep. 12 F8 RC/IC: "Bermuda Triangle" - Wins by a toe (on one foot) after 3 hours, over Brenda (1st/8).
    • Caramoan Ep. 12 F7 IC: "Fun Climb" - Tied for last with Dawn and Sherri (tie - 5th/7).


    Redemption/Exile Island duel record: (0-for-0)

    • Caramoan: None.
  • S34 logo Game Changers challenges (click to expand/collapse)

    Serpent Turf - Ep2 RC/IC

    Tribal/team challenge record (10.0*-for-13):

    • Game Changers Ep. 1 RC/IC: "Blue Lagoon Bustle" - Crosses various obstacles, and Nuku wins!
    • Game Changers Ep. 2 RC/IC: "Serpent Turf" - Hauls the giant snake, and Nuku wins again.
    • Game Changers Ep. 3 RC/IC: "Austin's EOC" - Crosses the obstacles for Tavua, who finish second (2nd*/3).
    • Game Changers Ep. 4 IC: "Ow Pairs" - Retrieves bags, plates the winning ball, and Tavua wins (1st/3).
    • Game Changers Ep. 5 RC: "Unchained Medley" - Crosses the beam holding the paddle, and Tavua wins (1st/3).
    • Game Changers Ep. 5 IC: "Box Car Blues" - Carries sandbags across the beam; Tavua doesn't lose (2nd*/3).
    • Game Changers Ep. 6 IC: "Cargo Salvage" - Now with Nuku, crosses barriers and hauls stuff, but Nuku loses.
    • Game Changers Ep. 7 RC: "Dulcimer Stomp" - Runs around the maypole with Ozzy and Sarah, and Nuku wins.
    • Game Changers Ep. 7 IC: "Plunge, Pop, Pull" - Tries to work the word puzzle, but Nuku loses.
    • Game Changers Ep. 9 RC: "New School" - With Tai, hooks fish and carries the pole for the winning team.
    • Game Changers Ep. 10 RC: "O Black Water" - Crosses water obstacles for the winning team.
    • Game Changers Ep. 11 RC: "Angry Chair" - With Zeke & Brad, works the word puzzle for the winning team.
    • Game Changers Ep. 12 RC: "Full Tilt Boogey" - With Brad & Aubry, crosses obstacles for the winning team.

    *Note: Second-place finishes in the three-tribe phase of Game Changers count as half a win.


    Keep on Your Toes - Ep8 IC

    Individual challenge record (2-for-6): (Mean % finish: 69.4%)

    • Game Changers Ep. 8 IC: "Keep on Your Toes" - Outlasts everyone, over 25 minutes, Andrea wins! (1st/13).
    • Game Changers Ep. 9 IC: "Get a Grip" - Second-to-last to drop out, at the 40-minute mark (3rd/12).
    • Game Changers Ep. 10 IC: "Got a Hunch" - One of ten people to not beat Troyzan (tie-2nd/11).
    • Game Changers Ep. 11 IC: "High Step and Stack" - First to get her tiles lined up, and Andrea wins! (1st/10).
    • Game Changers Ep. 12 IC: "Can't Buoy Me Love" - Third person to drop out, very quickly (7th/9).
    • Game Changers Ep. 13 F8 IC: "Teeter Tower" - Comes close, drops her stack, does not beat Aubry (tie-2nd/9).


    Redemption/Exile Island duel record: (0-for-0)

    • Game Changers: None yet.
Career challenge totals
  • Team/tribal challenges
    Wins: 22.0*
    Played: 32
    Win%: 0.69
    Sat out: 1
  • Individual challenges
    Wins: 4
    Played: 20
    Win%: 0.20
    Mean% Finish: 64.0%
  • Duels
    Wins: 1.25*
    Played: 2
    Win%: 0.50
    Mean% Finish: 63%
Andrea Boehlke - Tribal Council record
  • S22 logo Redemption Island Tribal (click to expand/collapse)

    Ep11 F7 Tribal Council

    Idols held/played (0/0):

    • Redemption Island: None.


    VFB - Votes for the person booted (7/11):

    • Redemption Island, Ep. 4: Kristina Kell (voted out, 4-3).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 8: Matt Elrod (voted out, again, 6-5-1).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 9 (F11 vote): Mike Chiesl (voted out, 6-5).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 9 (F10 vote): David Murphy (voted out, 6-4).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 10: Julie Wolfe (voted out, 6-3).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 11 (F8 vote): Ralph Kiser (voted out, 6-2).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 11 (F7 vote): Steve Wright (voted out, 6-1).


    VAP - Votes against (9):

    • Redemption Island, Ep. 12: Five votes, from Rob, Phillip, Natalie, Ashley, and Grant (voted out, 5-1).
    • Redemption Island, Ep. 14 (F5 vote): Four votes, from Rob, Phillip, Natalie, and Ashley (voted out again, 4-1).


    Jury votes made (1/1):

  • S26 logo Caramoan Tribal (click to expand/collapse)

    Ep1 Tribal Council

    Idols held/played: (1/0)

    • Caramoan, Ep. 12: Wins the clue to the idol in the F8 immunity challenge, which Erik finds for her and gives to her. Then she's blindsided with the idol in her pocket at the second Tribal Council that same episode.


    VFB - Votes for the person booted (6/8):


    VAP - Votes against (13):

    • Caramoan, Ep. 1: Four votes, from Francesca, Brandon, Brenda, and Erik.
    • Caramoan, Ep. 9: Three votes, from Reynold, Eddie, and Michael.
    • Caramoan, Ep. 11: Three votes, from Reynold, Eddie, and Malcolm.
    • Caramoan, Ep. 12 (F7 vote): Three votes, from Sherri, Erik, and Brenda (voted out, 3-2-2).


    Jury votes made (1/1):

    • Caramoan, Ep. 14: Voted for John Cochran (who won, 8-0-0).
  • S34 logo Game Changers Tribal (click to expand/collapse)

    Ep6 Tribal Council

    Idols held/played: (0/0)

    • Game Changers: None.


    VFB - Votes for the person booted (5/8):


    VAP - Votes against (14):

    • Game Changers, Ep. 10: Five votes, from Brad, Debbie, Sierra, Tai, and Troyzan.
    • Game Changers, Ep. 12: Three votes, from Brad, Sierra, and Troyzan.
    • Game Changers, Ep. 13 (F8 vote): Six votes, from Brad, Cirie, Michaela, Sarah, Tai, and Troyzan (voted out, 6-2).

    RECORD: Andrea's 36 career votes against are an all-time record.


    Jury votes made (1/1):

    • Game Changers, Ep. 14: Voted for Sarah Lacina, who won (7-3-0).
Career Tribal Council totals
  • Hidden idols
    Found: 1
    Played: 0
    Votes voided: --
  • Voting record
    VFB: 18
    Tribals: 27
    VAP: 36
  • Jury votes
    Made: 3
    For winners: 3
    Received: --
Andrea Boehlke - Pictures
  • S22 logo Redemption Island image gallery
  • S26 logo Caramoan image gallery (click to expand/collapse)
  • S34 logo Game Changers image gallery (click to expand/collapse)
Andrea Boehlke - Interviews
Andrea Boehlke - Bios
  • S22 logo Redemption Island bio (click to expand/collapse)

    From her EW photo caption:

    "Andrea may be only 21 years old, but she already has plenty of experience outdoors. 'I've been hunting and camping my whole life. I've shot seven deer and I've also hunted turkeys and lot of different kind of fowl.' And now she's hunting human game!!! But this natural flirt also hopes to kill with kindness. Does that mean a showmance could be in her future? 'There's really only three [hot] guys. Honestly, I think I've been checking out the girls more.' Alrighty then!"


    Excerpts from her official CBS bio page:

    "Personal Claim to Fame: Paying for my own college education and making the Dean's list every semester.


    Survivor Contestant You Are Most Like: Perhaps a mixture of J.T. because he is hard-working and has a farm background and Parvati because she's competitive and knows how to have fun, but I'm also very unique.


    Why you think you'll 'survive' Survivor: Growing up on a farm and being a member of the 4-H club has made me both outdoorsy and resourceful. I'm also mentally tough and a bit of a social butterfly. I love being challenged and can handle the pressure.."


  • S26 logo Caramoan bio (click to expand/collapse)

    Excerpts from her official CBS Caramoan - Fans vs. Favorites bio page:


    "Personal Claim to Fame: Moving to New York from Wisconsin on a whim and I’m still here!


    If You Could Have 3 Things on The Island What Would They Be and Why? 1) Yoga mat – It could serve as tarp/blanket/world’s shortest slip ‘n slide. 2) Juggling balls filled with rice – I’ve always wanted this. 3) A Unicorn, but not one that could fly.


    Survivor Contestant You Are Most Like: I guess I’m a smidge like Stephenie LaGrossa when it comes to being a force in challenges and being a bit of a tomboy."


  • S34 logo Game Changers bio (click to expand/collapse)

    Excerpts from her official CBS Game Changers bio page:


    "How have you changed since the last time you played? 
    I’m older and wiser! I was only 21 the first time I played Survivor and then 23 during my second season. I definitely feel more confident as a person, so, hopefully this translates to the game and I'm not-so paranoid.

    I'm also not so boy crazy, which is ideal!


    What skills do you bring to Survivor that will make you a useful member of the group and what skills have you been learning since you last played? 
    I'm confident in my challenge skills, so I know I'll be a great asset early on. After playing two seasons, I know how to work my social skills to form a solid group.

    My biggest hurdle will be to not come across as a schemer. In Caramoan, I was constantly on the chopping block for that reason, so I've been coming up with strategies to avoid that.


    How will you play differently this time? 
    I will have to play a low-key aggressive game. I definitely tried to overcorrect my Redemption Island game by playing very aggressively in Caramoan, but I think everyone could see I was trying to "make moves."

    I have to find some sort of balance between the two and also try to break away from my "us vs. them" old-fashioned way of playing the game. I have to be open to working with every single person."