San Juan del Sur intro shot

San Juan del Sur intro shot

CBS pre-game interview, with Jaclyn

EW pre-game interview, with Jaclyn

Pre-game posing. Wait... a former NCAA football player? On Survivor? That seems unlikely.

More pre-game posing, with Jaclyn

Even more pre-game posing, with Jaclyn

Taking the pre-game cast photo, with Jaclyn

Reading the Day Zero treemail, with Jaclyn

Day Zero confessional, also with Jaclyn

Reading the Day Zero treemail, with Jaclyn

Morning 1, raising his hand for having made fire

Pre-tribal split, listening to Natalie & Nadiya

Amused that Jeremy's duel will be against his wife

Ready to root for Jeremy, pre-Ep1 RC

Yay, Jeremy won!

Watching Keith get picked for Exile, Ep1

Working on the shelter with Drew, Day 1

In camp, with Jeremy, Kelley, and Reed

Messing with howler monkeys

Ep1 confessional about his ailing dad

Pensive

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep1 IC

Go!

First through the crawl!

Lifting Kelley up to collect a bag

Watching Drew secure the rope climb

Working Hunahpu's puzzle

Hunahpu, about to win, Ep1 IC

Watching Probst make his tribe feel bad for winning

Ep2 confessional: I didn't really lose the flint, but I might as well confess to it

Watching Natalie react to the Nadiya-less Coyopa's arrival, Ep2 RC

Watching Julie compete, Ep2 RC

Yay, Julie won

Thinking he would like the fishing gear they just won more than flint, Ep2

Oh well, at least we have fire

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep2 IC

Helping Kelley back onto the platform after her first-bout loss

Ready to battle Rocker, Ep2 IC

Jon-John is on

Success!

Story checks out

Looking at the reward, pre-Ep3 RC

Huh. Keith lost. Oh well.

Hunahpu discusses Rocker's past, post-Ep3 RC

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep3 IC

Ready to go, with Natalie

Scoring a point

Hunahpu yells at Rocker

Now scoring the winning point

With Drew, pondering the discovery of the extra flint

Standing ovation for the Rocker-less Coyopas, pre-Ep4 RC

Amused at Drew's attempt to trade the extra flint

Ready to compete against Jaclyn, Ep4 RC

About to land a shot

Focusing

Post-RC hug with Jaclyn

Talking about Exile with Probst

Who should I send with Jaclyn?

Talking about the decision to send Drew

Impersonating Drew

Watching Drew throw away immunity, Ep4 IC

Post-challenge discussion with Drew

Floating a plan for a couples alliance

Instantly shot down

Thanks, Drew!

Listening to Drew planning to target Kelley, with Kelley standing feet away

Dude!

Real talk with Drew

Hunahpu heads to its first Tribal Council

Hunahpu, Ep4 Tribal Council

Listening to Drew

Talking to Probst

Complimenting Kelley and Natalie on booting Drew

So long, Drew

Talking about Tribal, early Ep5

Post-Tribal apology tour

Listening to Probst, pre-Ep5 swap

Buff dropped, ready to swap

Now with New Coyopa

Happy to be swapped to a tribe with Jaclyn

The first of many of these shots

See?

...and this one

Talking alliance options with Jaclyn

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep5 IC

Listening to Probst

Go!

Digging deep, as Hunahpu races ahead, Ep5 IC

That did not go as hoped

Post-challenge lecture from Probst

Getting recruited by Dale and Kelley

More pitch listening, with Jaclyn

Now entertaining offers from Missy and Baylor, Ep5

New Coyopa, Ep5 Tribal Council

Talking about being in the middle of two alliances (with Jaclyn)

Good question, early Ep6

An idol, you say?

Yep, it sure looks like an idol!

Discussing who will compete, pre-Ep6 RC

Ready to watch Reed vs. Baylor

Baylor... possibly not the best choice

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep6 IC

Collecting bags

Working the puzzle for Coyopa

That doesn't look right...

Lost again

Except for the winning part

Post-challenge lecture from Probst

Listening to Dale's pitch, Ep6

Dale promises to give Jon his fake idol after the vote

Sounds good to me!

Making actual plans with Missy and Baylor

Talking things over with Jaclyn

Jaclyn seems skeptical

Coyopa, Ep6 Tribal Council

Talking to Probst

Waiting for the vote reveal

Hauling stuff to the merge feast, Ep7

Excited about the merge feast

Merge feasting

Heading back to camp

Checking back in with Jeremy

With Jaclyn, discussing merge tribe names

Listening to Josh's recruitment attempt

Talking alliance options with Jaclyn, again

Going through Julie's bag, of course

Found it

Eating the trail mix before Julie gets back

Angry, angry young man

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep7 IC

Ready to go...

Still in it...

Holding his balls

Alec sure wishes he had some trail mix

More consulting with Jaclyn

Listening to Probst announce Julie's quit

Post-merge balance of power, Ep7

Another talk with Jaclyn, early Ep8

We were going to boot Jeremy, but we'll still entertain other offers.

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep8 RC

Less excited to listen to Probst than Wes, apparently

Blue team, ready to lose

Pushing the sled full of puzzle pieces, with Alec

Still working on the puzzle, yellow team about to win

Me? Go to Exile? Fine.

Not pleased to be exiled, but spoiler alert: it turns out okay

Just one urn to open now

Reading the fairly simple clue

Off to find the idol

Yup, there it is

Almost there...

Found and hashtagged

Told you it would work out

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep8 IC

Trying to remember stuff

Whoops.

That was quick

Watching Jeremy get his necklace, post-Ep8 IC

Indeed.

Learning about the way the men treated Jaclyn in his absence

Maybe we won't boot Jeremy then. Also, he's immune.

So true

Spilling Jeremy's plans to Josh and his alliance

You probably shouldn't

Huyopa, Ep8 Tribal Council

Listening to Probst, with Jaclyn

Yup, we're in the middle again

Foreshadowing stabbing Jeremy in the back, early Ep9

Oh no! We might not be in the middle next time!

Not to worry, there's time to get back in the middle

Huyopa arrives, Ep9 RC

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep9 RC

Listening to Probst

Blue team, ready for their traditional losing spot

Watching Jaclyn vs. Natalie

Beating Jeremy, first bout

Facing off against Jeremy again

Just beat him again

With Jaclyn, getting reward despite losing (thanks Natalie and Jeremy)

Exiling Jeremy in gratitude

Heading out to reward

Yay, dolphins!

Talking about enjoying the food again

Cheers!

Another rare kissing shot

Another strategy discussion with Jaclyn

Thinking maybe it's time to target Jeremy

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep9 IC

Listening to Jeremy talk about Exile

Ready to go, Ep9 IC

...and Baylor wins.

Learning that Keith also has an idol

We are free to boot Jeremy, then!

Playing dumb about having found the Exile idol, to Jeremy

Passing the Jeremy boot plan on to Missy

Huyopa, Ep9 Tribal Council

Arguing with Wes and Keith about idols

Trying to pull Natalie back in, early Ep10

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep10 RC

Yellow team, ready to win

Giving Wes a temporary lead

Getting a key closeup

Working the puzzle, with Reed

And done.

Exiling Wes

Yay, free baseball stuff!

Handing out supplies

Delighted to be offered food

Mmm, eating

Feeding local kids ice cream

Talking about kids, and Jaclyn's MRKH syndrome

Impersonating Jeff Kent

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep10 IC

Ep10 IC, now in progress

Gazing longingly at Probst's plate of partially chewed candy

The last temptation of Jon

Snickerrrrrrrs!

Waiting for the challenge to end

Laughing about Probst's 2.5 Men cameo

Getting played by Alec, pre-Ep10 Tribal

Time to split the vote against Keith and Wes!

Huyopa heads to Tribal

Huyopa, Ep10 Tribal Council

Stick to the plan!

Free hints from Natalie

Seriously!

Successful idol play

Yes.

Nice try, Reed

Hey! That wasn't very nice.

Yay, not voted out, early Ep11

Lecturing Jaclyn about jury management

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep11 RC

Getting the first one right

Micromanaging the collusion

Sorry, Alec's not-broken skull

Discussing who gets to 'win,' Ep11 RC

Volunteering for Exile again.

Okay! Time for another idol!

Groan, so much more walking

Yup, there it is

Hashtagged again

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep11 IC

Battling Keith, Ep11 IC

Getting filled in on camp happenings by Jaclyn

That didn't go so well...

Almost plotting with Reed, when a hovering Natalie appears

Getting another hashtag

Telling Missy about his idol

Not talking to Jaclyn

Still not talking to Jaclyn

Huyopa, Ep11 Tribal Council

Talking to Probst about his dispute with Jaclyn

So long, Reed

Yup

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep12 RC

Ready to go, Ep12 RC

Still going...

Having problems

Done

Getting reward from Natalie, anyway

Yay, a bed with wine and food.

Cheers!

Mmm, food

Mmm, wine

Mmm, bed

That's not very nice, Baylor

Jon will be sacrificed for this season's sins

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep12 IC

Listening to Baylor

Ready to go, Ep12 IC

So far, so good

Getting closer...

...and done.

Yay, immunity

Having an idol and a necklace is pretty sweet!

Listening to Natalie, Ep12 Tribal Council

Talking about his dad

What? ALEC got voted out?

Seems legit

Well... it kind of is...

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep13 RC

Blue team, ready to... win?

Missy, having problems

...and more problems

Just got to the puzzle

Almost there...

Blue team wins!

I'm swapping myself out for Baylor!

Watching Natalie get exiled

Missing out on spa day is not so bad, get to hang out with Jaclyn

Is it possible Natalie didn't forget to vote for Keith?

Pre-challenge lineup, Ep13 IC

Finally getting to the challenge, as Missy gets medical attention

Ready to go, Ep13 IC

Still going...

D'oh!

Watching Probst congratulate Natalie on her IC win

Now behind Natalie

Still feeling comfortable in his five

Kissing Jaclyn again

Seriously, though. Are we sure Natalie's really with us?

Uh huh.

Hmmm.

Shockingly, another kiss

...and again

Heading to his final Tribal

Huyopa, Ep13 Tribal Council

Listening to Jaclyn

Stick to the plan.

What?

Who did that?

Sigh

Watching the re-vote reveal

One more kiss...

Whoops, forgot something

Snuffed, Ep13

Final Tribal Council, the jury assembles

Asking his question

Reunion, waiting for the final vote reveal

Reunion Q&A with Probst