Okay, so we’re the absolute last people in the entire world to comment on (let alone watch) Star Wars, Episode III: Revenge of the Sith, but a couple of questions troubled us. No, not “Did Natalie Portman really get nominated for an Oscar?”, but more Lucasverse-centric (translation: geeky) questions. Mainly of continuity and/or plausibility. Such as:
- Palpatine was intimately involved in the Clone Army project. He’s had his eye on Anakin since he was Little eventually-Orphan Ani, the scampy pod racer. Even as late as the transformation to Darth “Mostly Armless” Vader, couldn’t Palpy have scrapped the silly Jango Fett prototype, and started up the Stormtrooper 2.0 project with a few of Anakin’s amputated cells? You’d think an army of Chosen Ones might kick a bit of ass. Admittedly, Anakin sucks at following orders, but you’d think at the very least El Sid(ious) would want a couple of backup Anakins in the pipeline, you know, just in case the original loses a limb or two, slips into hot lava, or otherwise gets killed at some later date. There certainly should be plenty of spare lightsabers they could have cleaned up from the Jedi temple. Stupid Sith lords.
- For a group of people who can levitate themselves, heavy seating saucers, doors, boulders and the like, Jedi sure seem to spend a lot of time desperately hanging onto ledges by their fingertips. You’d think they’d at least start a seminar series on it for the padawans, or something.
- Why is it that Yoda and Obi-Wan can detect disturbances in the Force when people (not even Jedi) die light-years away from them, or detect Vader’s presence, but they have no clue that there’s a powerful practitioner of the Dark Side right next to them? And Anakin can, with certainty (or at least enough to convince Mace Windu)?
- If the redshirt Jedi masters that Palpatine hacked through like tissue paper were such lightweights, shouldn’t Mace Windu have thought about waiting for Yoda before trying to arrest the super-dangerous Sith lord? Stupid, stupid Jedi.
But maybe we’re just grumpy that our excellent casting suggestions were ignored…
